Homeland Security Watch

News and analysis of critical issues in homeland security

April 29, 2009

The Senators, the Secretary, and Dr. Shuchat speak

Filed under: General Homeland Security — by Philip J. Palin on April 29, 2009

Beginning at 10:05 am this morning Secretary Napolitano and Rear Admiral Anne Shuchat M.D. of the Centers for Disease Control are testifying before the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs.  (If you have a broadband connection, you can access the webcast.)

The following is a real-time posting.  I intend to restrict my attention to the broader policy-with-practice nexus on which this blog is attempting to focus.  Later today I will post media coverage of the hearing.

Chairman Lieberman opens by saying, “This is a case when the government was prepared for the crisis.”   He emphasizes the Secretary of Homeland Security has been given authority, by statute and presidential directive, to serve as the federal government’s  emergency manager. 

The Chairman quickly reviews a history of relevant law-making and policy-making.  In particular he highlights the  National Strategy for Pandemic Influenza Implementation Plan.

Senator Collins, the ranking Republican, highlights the importance and role of the Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority.  She also raises concerns regarding bio-surveillance, distribution of countermeasures, and interagency communication/collaboration.

Secretary Napolitano repeats that the Secretary of  Homeland Security is the Principal Federal Officer for Domestic Incident Management (as per HSPD-5, but she did not make this specific cite).  She says, “At the Department of Homeland Security we are moving ahead in accord with planning and frameworks that have been in place for many years.”

The Secretary clarifies that, “statutory authority exists to close specific ports, but not the border as a whole.”  But in the current case, such action would not be scientifically justified.

Dr. Shuchat gives substantial attention to the Strategic National Stockpile and an emergency use authority.  The admiral referenced a variety of preparedness activitities that have been engaged, but she is not specific. As a result of these efforts  she says,” at no time in our nation’s history have we been as well-prepared as we are today.”

Dr. Shuchat began, I think, to explain how prior plans and studies to deal with Avian Flu did contemplate containment strategies (very roughly analogous to closing the border).  But those plans and studies anticipated very early identification of human-to-human transmission in an isolated location (not analogous to the current situation).  But Senator McCain did not recognize where she was going.

Responding to the admiral’s assertion that she cannot foresee the need to close the border, the Chairman may be confusing social-distancing tactics from a containment strategy.  The Secretary responds to both Senator McCain and the Chairman attempting to take the issue off the table.

The question of medical mutual aid agreements is raised.  These exist.  They have been created at the state and regional levels. But Dr. Shuchat cautions that prior planning — and the prospect of a wide-spread epidemic — may cause  communities to be unwilling to share and medical professionals may be reluctant to relocate.

Information on school closures and related social-distancing options  is being distributed.  CDC is inclined to defer to local judgment on this matter.  The Secretary says this has been a topic of conversation with governors and mayors.

A “decision-to-vaccinate”  is an entirely separate decison from the decision to  produce a vaccine. The Senators, the Secretary, and Dr. Shuchat all emphasize the importance of recognizing that these are very discreet issues… and need to be kept that way.  Evidently this was not the case with the Ft. Dix swine flu incident in 1976.

Senator Pryor asks the Secretary about possible lessons-learned.  While she concurs that lessons will be learned, she chooses not to respond directly.  She explains, “right now we are too much, in it.” (her emphasis)

11:34 –  I have a professional commitment that can no longer be delayed. Readers who are monitoring are invited to use the comment function to highlight other policy-with-practice aspects of the hearing.

2:00 pm – The hearing’s focus on virus-basics, closing-the-border, and vaccine production probably reflect where many citizens have concerns.  The Senator’s questions and statements provided another opportunity for raising awareness and educating the public.

I understand — but regret — Secretary Napolitano’s demurring on the opportunity to discuss early lessons-learned.   Anything she said in this setting and at this time would have been amplified beyond recognition.  But Senator Pryor was right to ask the question.  Here’s hoping the Secretary and many others are keeping notes for future reference.

The Secretary’s formal prepared testimony has now been released and provides helpful information on our policy-with-practice focus.  See next post above.


Eileen Sullivan with the Associated Press is also filing real-time: Napolitano asserts strong federal flu response and a more extensive follow-on story under the same headline.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Google Bookmarks
  • email
  • Print
  • LinkedIn


Comment by William R. Cumming

April 29, 2009 @ 9:39 am

My real bottom line on this is were all statutory and non-statutory (HSPD-5-8-21) met and trained on and understood by all concerned within the Executive Branch including appointees and civil servants? Why this bottom line? I have consistent information that since Exercise Dark Winter (Sam Nunn as President) and the first 4 TOPOFF Exercises and semblence of competence by Top Officials (the orginal source of TOPOFF) in those mandated NO-NOTICE (they are were heavily noticed to participants so they could get ducks in line) that had even a semblance of relationship to a PANDEMIC or Biological Terrorism Event were terribly handles by players at all level (federal-state-local). Sadly, Chris Schayes (former R. Conn.) who was instrumental in creating that series of exercises after learning the many Senior Clinton Administration officials did not ever play exericises or were afraid of demonstrating their incompetence and lack of knowledge and training)needed to be trained so they were NOT passing out business cards in real world events. Again, sadly but interetingly the renamed TOPOFF V is now NLE V (National Level Exercise) was to involve Mexico. They probably will be too busy now. I hope this is a really really tough hearing for the Administration. The fact that Pandemics historically have operated over substantial period of times and in waves means that just because this one “cools” off does not mean we are out of the woods. Also what is the travesty of blaming Susan Collins for deleting the $950M pandemic funding in the Stimulus Bill in February when she was just showing proper regards for the Authorization process in the Senate and appropriations process and now thank goodness the Adminstration which as recently as last week was stating over and over again that new funding was not necessary now is seeking $1.5 Billion. Let’s get going with basic competency and honesty both in Congress and the Executive Branch. I don’t know anything not open source but predicting Level 6 on WHO scale.

Comment by William R. Cumming

April 29, 2009 @ 10:39 am

I forgot to mention that any vaccine specific to the H1N1 is at least 10 months off. Collection and distribution of samples of H1N1 to Pharma potential producers will be the real starting point for any emergency production.

The discussion of the benefits of releases from the Strategic National Stockpile are probably overblown given past performance of the two primary distributed prophylactics.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>