UPDATE: Friday Morning: According to The Hill: “Senate Republicans blocked a $2.7 billion border spending bill Thursday in a 50-44 vote. The Senate voted against waiving a budget point of order on the measure, which would have provided funding for authorities to handle a wave of child immigrants crossing the border.” MORE.
Later today the House is expected to try again to pass a narrower package. According to Roll Call: “It could happen as early as Friday morning — the GOP will gather at 9 a.m. to discuss new policy proposals to accompany a $659 million appropriations bill they abruptly yanked from consideration Thursday. Republicans departing from an emergency conference meeting Thursday afternoon told reporters they felt confident that, through a process of educating colleagues and agreeing to make some changes to existing legislative language, they could muster enough votes to pass the new measure. MORE.
But with Senators already leaving town for a five-week recess, whatever the House does will be symbolic rather than substantive. The House will blame the Senate. Democrats will blame Republicans (and vice-versa). Congress will have fulminated and flailed, but in the end the legislative branch failed to act.
UPDATE: 4:30 Eastern: Republican leadership has announced the House will delay its recess until a vote is taken on border-related legislation. MORE from The Hill.
I will be driving for a couple of hours. Texting while driving is dangerous, blogging is worse. This is about all from me today… and tomorrow will not be a good day for me to be online. Blogging is not all I do.
As Bill Cumming mentioned, it’s been interesting to watch the “dance of legislation.” Beautiful ballet it ain’t.
UPDATE 3:00 Eastern: Several news outlets are reporting the House is unlikely to vote today on a border related supplemental. The Hill is using the word “canceled” in regard to the vote. Roll Call is using “postponed”, saying there is still a small chance of the vote being rescheduled. Just moments ago Politico led their coverage with, “The House descended into chaos on Thursday, unable to plot a path forward on a bill to address the border crisis.”
I have received email and voicemail from those claiming to be inside the process on Capitol Hill. Some I do not know. One writes, “Every effort at responsible legislative action is being countered by those, some Democrats and some Republicans, who threaten the political equivalent of all out war. This is not parliamentary maneuver or even political hard-ball, but hostage-taking and career-threatening extortion. It makes House of Cards look like Little House on the Prairie.”
It is my understanding that unless the House passes something, there will be nothing to reconcile with the Senate (presuming something emerges there) and legislative input to the oft-referenced “crisis” on the border will be null.
I’m told a meeting is just getting underway among Republican leaders to find some way through to more than null. I’ve got other work, but will be back when I can be.
UPDATE 1:30 Eastern: The Hill reports that Democrats in the House will not vote for the so-called Granger supplemental. This means divisions in the Republican caucus must be overcome for the legislation to pass in the House. The House is expected to vote early this afternoon. I will probably be offline when it happens… if it happens anytime close to schedule.
UPDATE Noon Eastern: Roll Call reports: “Just hours after shifting gears on a strategy to pass a $659 million appropriations bill to bolster resources at the U.S.-Mexico border, House Republicans are moving ahead, more confident they have the votes. Rank-and-file members emerged from a GOP Conference meeting at the Capitol Hill Club on Thursday morning with a sense that the gambit — giving conservatives a standalone vote to stop the expansion of President Barack Obama’s Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program after they pass the border funding bill — would be enough to bring conservative holdouts on board. MORE.
At 11:17 AM Reuters reported: ”The Congress on Thursday is set to debate “emergency” border security legislation that lawmakers acknowledge will not be enacted but will enable them to campaign for re-election by arguing they worked to address a humanitarian crisis. Republicans and Democrats have been sparring over President Barack Obama’s request for $3.7 billion to respond to the crisis in which tens of thousands of Central American children have tried to enter the United States illegally. With Congress on the verge of beginning its five-week summer recess, the votes in the Republican-controlled House of Representatives and Democratic-held Senate on Thursday will mark a holding pattern.” MORE.
UPDATE 11:00 Eastern: Statement by the White House Press Secretary: “It is extraordinary that the House of Representatives, after failing for more than a year to reform our broken immigration reform system, would vote to restrict a law enforcement tool that the Department of Homeland Security uses to focus resources on key enforcement priorities like public safety and border security, and provide temporary relief from deportation for people who are low priorities for removal. In the face of Congressional inaction, the Administration’s use of Deferred Action for DREAMers in 2012, which has benefitted more than 500,000 young people who are Americans in every way except on paper, is the most significant progress we have made toward immigration reform in years. By failing to act on an immigration reform bill that requires that people who are here illegally pay taxes, undergo background checks and get on the right side of the law, the House is instead driving an approach that is about rounding up and deporting 11 million people, separating families, and undermining DHS’ ability to secure the border.”
ORIGINAL THURSDAY MORNING POST:
Yesterday (Wednesday) late morning the Senate voted 63-to-33 to end debate on the emergency supplemental. (See Senate Appropriations Committee language.) This advanced the proposed appropriation toward floor amendments and an up-or-down vote. According to Politico, “GOP senators who don’t support the Senate Democrats’ package – which also includes funding for wildfire aid and for Israel’s Iron Dome missile defense system – lent their votes for the procedural vote in hopes of amending the measure more to their liking.”
Later today (Thursday) the House is expected to vote on a $659 million package. (See House Appropriation Committee’s supplemental language and funding amounts.) According to Roll Call, “Two-thirds of the funding will be for border security, with $40 million going to prevention and $197 million going to humanitarian assistance, according to a GOP aide. It will run through Sept. 30.”
The Republican caucus is not wholly on board. Last minute changes are possible. There is even some talk of passing the stop-gap measure with bipartisan votes, rare on big bills. According to The Hill, “House conservatives emerging from a late evening meeting in Cruz’s office said they would oppose the $659 million legislation and warned it might fail on the House floor, an embarrassing prospect for the new GOP leadership team.”
At 11PM Wednesday night, Roll Call reported:
In a bid to shore up votes for their border supplemental, Republican leaders plan to give conservatives a vote Thursday prohibiting President Barack Obama from granting deportation relief to more illegal immigrants. One vote will be on the $659 million appropriations bill aimed at curbing the flow of child migrants at the U.S.-Mexico border, which includes policy riders that have alienated nearly all Democrats. On the condition of that bill passing, members would then be allowed to a vote on standalone language prohibiting the expansion of President Barack Obama’s Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program granting deportation relief and work permits to children brought here illegally by their parents. Republicans charge DACA has acted as a magnet for unaccompanied children to come to the United States, although recent immigrants are not eligible.
Republican Senators McCain and Cornyn are rumored to be working on a version of the House bill that could pass the Senate, presumably as an in extremis measure. But Wednesday afternoon some White House staff threatened a Presidential veto if the House measure makes it through the Senate and to the other end of Pennsylvania Avenue.
As of Thursday dawn it does not appear likely that the House and Senate will reconcile their alternatives anytime soon. The Hill reports, “…before the House and Senate are to adjourn for a five-week recess, there is little chance that legislation dealing with the wave of immigrants crossing the border will reach President Obama’s desk.”
Both chambers are expected to complete work tonight. I will provide updates to this post throughout today as legislative action is taken.
Given the apparent division and indecision on Capitol Hill, it is interesting to see that a July 23-27 public opinion poll found significant public consensus related to the current border issue. Here are the results for two of the questions asked of a statistically valid sample:
Which statement comes closest to your views about what the U.S. should do about
the children who are currently arriving from Central America without their parents. We should…
70 percent Offer shelter and support while beginning a process to determine whether they should be deported or allowed to stay in the U.S.
26 percent Deport them immediately back to their home countries
2 percent None of these
2 percent Don’t know/Refused
Now I’m going to read you a few pairs of statements. For each pair, please tell me whether the FIRST statement or the SECOND statement comes closer to your own views — even if neither is exactly right. The first pair is… Which statement comes closer to your own view?
38 percent The families of children arriving from Central American are taking advantage of American good will and are really seeking a back door to immigrate to our country
56 percent The families of children arriving from Central American are doing what they can to keep their children safe in very difficult circumstances
3 percent Neither/Both (VOL.)
3 percent Don’t know/Refused (VOL.)
Joseph de Maistre wrote, “Every nation gets the government it deserves.” The American nation is authentically divided on many important issues. Our government reflects this division. But in this particular case, a significant majority of the people-as-a-whole seem wiser, more merciful, more generous than a majority — or a stubborn minority? — of our legislators.